Jack L. Paradise, MD, now retired, was the medical director of the Ambulatory Care Center at the Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh. He was also a professor in the pediatrics department at the University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine. Dr. Paradise’s primary research was focused on indications for tonsillectomy and adenoidectomy, and on the diagnosis, management, and clinical significance of otitis media.
Why did you develop the Paradise Criteria? Was there a particular clinical experience or patient encounter that inspired you to create this tool for clinicians?
When in pediatric practice in a new, union-sponsored health plan in Appalachia, I was often called upon to render judgment as to whether or not tonsillectomy was indicated for individual children for whom a recommendation for tonsillectomy had been made by other physicians. This procedure was instituted because health plan administrators believed that tonsillectomy often was being performed on children without appropriate indications. Accordingly, payment for tonsillectomy by the health plan was made contingent on prior approval by me or by another member of a health-plan-designated group of consultants. In that role, I came to realize that there were then no evidence-based criteria for tonsillectomy. Recommendations by recognized authorities varied widely and were based entirely on clinical experience and/or opinion. When I left practice to head an ambulatory care program in a large teaching hospital, I saw an opportunity to address the question of criteria for tonsillectomy systematically.Continue reading “Considering Tonsillectomy in Children: Interview with Dr. Jack L. Paradise, Paradise Criteria Creator”